Handel's Homemade Ice Cream in Indiana

"My lovely bride and I stopped by for some delicious ice cream. She had PB chocolate chunk and I had the black cherry. She liked hers but thought it could use a touch more PB for her taste. I thought mine was fine. Quite a few people here but the staff was quick and efficient. Yeah a little pricey for ice cream but I figure it’s Fishers so their overhead has to be kinda high. We will be back."

"Service 5 stars, and you can try your ice cream before you buy! The hurricane is softer virgin of iceream I really liked , but my favorite flavor by far was COFFEE."

"This was a great experience and good service with friendly staff. They have delicious ice cream. I love their Extra thick chocolate milkshake! You’re definitely not gonna go wrong with this place! Enjoy!"

"My to go place when I'm craving Pistachio flavored ice cream. The one thing I love the most is that it actually has a good amount of pistachios in it."

"I tried the sampler 4 dip. I got pistachio, coconut cream pie, smores and spouse big as a house. Let me tell you all the spouse one is amazing!! I loved it and wanted to lick the container!! Next was smores, it was also very good. The pistachio could use a little more flavor and the coconut cream was ok. Ill definitely visit again"

"One of the GEM in city, I love this home made ice creams. The 4 sampler is the best concept here, I wish other stores adapt this concept as well. My all time favourite is coconut pie, all the flavours are very good…… I like to eat different flavours every time I visit here. flavour of the month concept is crazy as well. This is the top of the best ice cream parlours ever."

"Amazing! I had the coconut cream pie, and it was hands down the best ice cream I’ve ever had. Sooo creamy and delicious! Pure perfection. The frosted animal cookie one was also really good. Others in the group had the coffee, cookie dough, and cake batter and all said they were fantastic. Not a bad price and worth the wait."

"A Sweet Treat Worth Waiting For I recently visited Handel's Homemade Ice Cream in Fishers, and it was a delightful experience. The ice cream is truly homemade and made fresh daily, offering an impressive selection of over 50 flavors. Highlights: - Delicious Flavors: From classic Chocolate Pecan to unique flavors like Graham Central Station and Cake Batter, there's something for everyone. - Homemade Goodness: The ice cream is crafted in-house using high-quality ingredients and traditional recipes. - Friendly Service: Despite the long lines, the staff is courteous and accommodating. Area for Improvement: - Service Speed: Be prepared for potentially long wait times, as the lines can easily go around the building. While the staff is friendly, the service could use some speed to manage the crowds more efficiently. Tips: - Try their sampler option to taste multiple flavors. - Consider visiting during off-peak hours to avoid long lines. - Don't miss out on their seasonal flavors and unique creations"